Lyra Rembrandt vs Prismacolor Premier Review

It’s important to admit when you have an obsession and one of mine happens to be with colored pencils. On a recent trip to Costco, I came across a set of 24 Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor colored pencils for a steal of a deal, so how could I not purchase them?! I mean they were practically begging me to take them home at the $10 CAD sticker price and the graphic designer in me is always a sucker for pretty packaging.

In the February issue of Colored Pencil Magazine, Ivar Harrison reviewed these pencils and it had peaked my interest enough that I felt I needed to try them for myself. After my initial post about my purchase, I had a question on my Facebook art page asking how these wax based pencils compared to Prismacolor Premier. I had only tried them out in a quick color chart in one of my sketchbooks so I didn’t have what I felt was an accurate or fair answer, especially in comparison to Prismacolor. It made sense, naturally, that I would put the two brands to the test.

SKIP TO MY REVISED REVIEW HERE WITH IMPROVED CONTENT AND PHOTOS: LYRA VS PRISMACOLOR

Please also note that some of the links in this post are affiliate links and if you go through them to make a purchase I will earn a commission. Keep in mind that I link these companies and their products because of their quality and not because of the commission I receive from your purchases. The decision is yours, and whether or not you decide to buy something is completely up to you.

PRODUCT SPECS

  • Lyra is a German-based company in association with the FILA group of companies
  • Rembrandt Polycolor sets come in 78 colors in a hinged metal tin
  • Light and water resistance
  • 4mm leads with a cedar barrel
  • Excellent lightfast rating amongst almost all of the colors (in the 24 set)

PACKAGING

The company has taken the time to put a premium effort in the packaging and presentation of this product even though its price is quite economical. Normally a metal tin is something you would see and expect from the higher price point colored pencil brands. For me, that is an attention to detail element that I appreciate about this company and makes me interested to see how this product may evolve. Although I love the cardboard sleeve with the beautiful pomegranate illustration and color chart on the back, this is the only feature I find a little disappointing.

Split photo of the Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor outside sleeve and a close up of the pencils

If you chose to discard this sleeve, you lose all the product information with it. Sure you could look it up online, but it’s nice to have right there on the container. Also, I found it hard to source this information on Lyra’s website.

Pre-Test Disclaimer
For the purpose of my experiment, I am using Strathmore Bristol Smooth Surface 300 Series paper. This is a favorite pairing of mine with Prismacolor.  I chose an image of a toucan bird that had a lot of the colors represented in the set of 24 Lyra colored pencils I had purchased.

To also ensure as fair as possible of a comparison, I used similar pencil colors in both brands. The only blending aid used was a Caran D’Ache colourless blender on both. Normally in a comparison of this type, I would complete one drawing in the one brand first entirely and then the next. This time, I rendered them in equal steps, so that I could get a very direct comparison.

SINGLE COLOUR APPLICATION

After applying the black areas first I noticed a couple of things. The Lyra black has a warmer hue to it than the Prismacolor Premier black does. The Lyra pencils had a very buttery and softer feel as well compared to the Prismacolor. It was actually quite a noticeable difference for me, similar to the difference between Prismacolor and Faber-Castell Polychromos, with the latter having a noticeably harder lead. The black coverage was pretty good with the Lyra pencils but I definitely felt like the Prismacolor pencils have more overall saturation to the pigment. By this, I mean that it seemed to take fewer strokes to fill the paper tooth with color with Prismacolor compared to Lyra.

Inital rendering using black in both Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor and Prismacolor Premier

SHARPENING & BREAKAGE

The Lyra pencils sharpened to a point well and held that point with minimal breakage.

DETAILS & MULTIPLE COLOUR APPLICATION

In my next applications of color, I noticed that the colors got a little muddy if they came in too close of contact with the black on the Lyra example. This was not the case on the Prismacolor version. With detailed, color applications over other colors, the Lyra again didn’t seem to have as crisp of an application, even when sharpened to a point.

BLENDING

Blending was pretty good with the Lyra’s but I found it seemed problematic when trying to use a burnishing technique to blend 2 colors together. I think this type of pencil might be better using a slow blend/ build up method. Both brands responded very well to the Caran D’Ache colourless blender.

Blending examples using Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor and Prismacolor Premier

FINAL RESULT

Despite some technical differences, the colors are very vibrant and at a glance, you wouldn’t really notice a huge difference in the result.

Final demo drawings of a toucan using Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor and Prismacolor Premier

OVERALL WINNER

My overall winner in this battle was Prismacolor Premier based on feel and technical application. With that said, Lyra is a formidable opponent in its own way. Having a lot of experience with Prismacolor, I know it’s strengths and weaknesses. In a direct comparison with another product, those qualities become more pronounced on either side. For me, the Lyra pencils will most likely be my go-to for sketchbook studies.

WHY YOU SHOULD PURCHASE LYRA REMBRANDT

– an extremely affordable price point for the quality
– great range of available colors
– great lightfast rating on the majority of the colors  *Updated Sept 3, 2018
– clear outer marking of the color name and color label
– comes with a metal tin for safe storage
– great sharpening consistency and point

If you are new to colored pencil or are on a strict budget for your art materials, Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor is an excellent choice to get you started. Though I personally found some of the application of the product not to my preference, it’s worth trying it yourself with your specific techniques and paper choice.

UPDATED CONTENT

***UPDATE*** September 3rd, 2018
After reviewing the independent test conducted by The Colored Pencil Society of America, 11 of the 24 colors in the Lyra Rembrandt set I used were found to be rated 5.4 or less or inferior. Some of the colors on the packaging that are very highly rated were included in the colors that failed to pass the test conducted by the CPSA.
 Of the 72 colors tested 26 tested 6.1-8 (good or very good) only 5 rated 5 5.5-6 (fair). The rest tested in the 5.4 or less. This is something to consider when less than 50% of the colors have been found to be unacceptable for long-term lightfastness.

Why does this happen?
Each company uses their own rating system and it’s hard to tell with most whether they are following the ATSM Standard D6901 or perhaps something else. Compliance is also not mandatory.

Despite these findings, I still believe that these are great affordable colored pencils for hobbyists who aren’t selling their work. However, if you purchase these with the intention of selling the originals you created with them, you may not be able to guarantee against fading if you use colors listed on the fugitive list.

Related: Does Lightfast Really Matter?

Something Else to Consider (paraphrased from the CPSA Lightfast Workbook):
The consistency of a color to last over time depends on a few factors including the substrate upon which it was used, quality of framing materials and practices, fixatives and glazes as well as the environment in which the artwork is placed. Prolonged exposure to sunlight and fluctuating humidity and temperature can all create adverse effects on even highly rated colors.

https://amzn.to/3akxZRY

For more on the CPSA and the study they conducted visit: https://www.cpsa.org/about/testing-by-cpsa/

For more on Lyra: http://www.lyra.de/produktfamilien/kuenstlerbedarf/lyra-rembrandt-polycolor/

For more on Prismacolor Premier: http://www.prismacolor.com/products/colored-pencils

Have you tried Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor colored pencils? What was your experience? Share with me in the comments!

7 thoughts on “Lyra Rembrandt vs Prismacolor Premier Review

  1. maudietighe says:

    It was hardly a review in the coloured pencil magazine. Got the issue to read it and yours was far far better. Why that was even in the magazine I don’t know. It said how soft they are, and how many come in a tin.

    • BarbSotiArt says:

      Thank you for your comment! I’ve rarely come across a perfect product, so I think it makes sense to show both sides. That being said everyone’s opinions are different on what they think is good or bad. As for the review in the magazine, I’ve noticed the focus has been mostly on the technical specs of the products being reviewed. It’s worth submitting some feedback if you think the article would be more valuable with a more balanced perspective. ๐Ÿ˜Š

  2. martina.franklin.poole says:

    I “paint” with my Prismas and rarely sharpen to a point. It is my theory that they break inside before they are sharpened, so I don’t mail order and I handle them gently. I love your review and I like the Prisma sample best, but I’m biased!
    M

    • BarbSotiArt says:

      Hi Martina! Thanks for your comment! I agree, there’s definitely something suspect going on with Prismacolor and the breakage. You’re smart to take precautions. I hope some of the quality issues can be resolved since I like the feel of them and the breakage is frustrating for sure. ๐Ÿ˜•

  3. painterwrite says:

    Great post! Personally, I don’t like Prismacolor except when I want to do a rich, deep application of black. i just find them too soft and too “breaky”. I bought a 12-pack of Lyra and liked them so much i ended up buying the big tin. They do yield more subtle color than FC Polychromos (my pencil of choice) or Prismacolor, but I liked the feel of them. My biggest complaint is that, in most cases, the lead color of Lyra doesn’t match the color indicator on the end of the pencil very well which means more time spent sorting out color choices.

    • BarbSotiArt says:

      There’s definitely quality issues with Prismacolor in terms of breakage so I totally agree with you there. I think feel is a huge part of what makes a good colored pencil and there’s definitely some individual preference factors in that. I totally think Lyra’s are worth trying because like you, people might find they really like them. Colors not matching is a huge pet peeve of mine which is 100% why I always make color charts. Seems tedious but I find it a time saver in the end. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

Leave a Reply